Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

New Who 11.1 The Woman Who Fell To Earth

Ooh! That was good, wasn't it? Good enough to make me want to write about it here, anyway, which I haven't managed for the last season-and-a-half.

Jodie Whittaker definitely gives good Doctor. Just the right balance between warm and human and strange without being too mannered. And I liked how the extended episode time allowed plenty of space to develop and introduce all the characters. I'm not sure I was wild about the alien threat, who felt a bit two-dimensional, but then again I get how you need a fairly simple villain when the real business of the episode is introducing a new Doctor and her companions, and I did enjoy the stuff about how he was cheating his way to get power, and what kind of leader did that mean he was going to make? Definitely felt like a broken-state-of-modern-politics reference to me.

I like how the Doctor built her new sonic screwdriver / Swiss army knife out of actual Sheffield steel, and chose her new outfit from a charity shop. And I liked the use of the cranes, too. As someone who regularly drives through Sheffield (on my way between Leeds and Birmingham), they are very much one of the major icons of the city to me. In the run-up to Christmas, they string lights along them. Oh, and the drunk guy mocking the alien dude by saying "Halloween's next month, mate." That felt like a shout-out to all the Goths - and perhaps also a sign that the original plan was to broadcast this episode slightly earlier in the year, as of course Halloween is in fact now later this month.

I could really have done with Grace not dying, partly because she was just awesome and I wanted her on the TARDIS team, and partly because it felt like a rather token, deliberate mechanism for signalling how High the Stakes are in the Doctor's world. But at least, if that was going to be the case, they gave time and space to the consequences of her death, to the extent of showing her funeral - have we ever even had a funeral in Doctor Who before? I can't think of one. Anyway, of the team that's left, I'm pretty sure Graham is going to be my favourite as we go on. He seems very kind and good-hearted, and I just loved his very relatable and human focus on the threats they were facing - like the way he was the one who kept going back to the issue of the DNA bombs, and how long did they have?

It's too early to be sure how this new era will pan out, or what Chris Chibnall has lined up, but I certainly didn't get much sense of any Big Arc being established - I mean, no Crack in Time or Impossible Girl or anything like that. Just the Doctor and some randomly-collected people off for an adventure into space. That actually makes it feel fresher and more exciting than I think all Moffat's Big Arcs generally did, so I hope things stay that way. Here's to a new era.

Dreamwidth version | comment count unavailablecomments | Leave a comment


( 7 comments — Leave a comment )
Oct. 8th, 2018 07:09 am (UTC)
Argh, wasn't it good? I went round and watched it with friends, which I haven't done since, I think, Tennant's first one.

I am claiming the spoon-brandishing as a 7th Doctor reference.
Oct. 10th, 2018 11:25 am (UTC)
I watched this on the IPlayer on the strength of your review Penny! And I really enjoyed it! So thank you for that :-)
I liked the humour - especially the Tim Shaw silliness, and I've set the recorder to make sure I don't miss the next episode :-)
Oct. 10th, 2018 07:40 pm (UTC)
Very glad to hear you enjoyed it! And yes I very much agree (re your second comment) about the diversity. Quite apart from being a positive thing in terms of helping to improve tolerance and social cohesion, it just offers so many more character development and story possibilities.
Oct. 10th, 2018 11:27 am (UTC)
Also, woman doctor and diverse cast - age and ethnicity - what a great thing! :-)
May. 7th, 2019 06:50 am (UTC)
I just watched this episode and I knew Grace was a goner because she was having too much fun. It is such a shame that her nurse skills won't be used ever again.
May. 7th, 2019 04:36 pm (UTC)
Yes, she would have been great in the rest of the series. It's still really good, though! Hope you enjoy the rest of it. :-)
May. 8th, 2019 10:36 am (UTC)
Thanks. I don't mind if I get spoiled by accident at this point. I just finished seeing episode four. :)

Edited at 2019-05-08 10:36 am (UTC)
( 7 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

April 2019


Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by chasethestars